☕ Coffee, Cholesterol & Antioxidants – What You Really Need to Know

Many of us love our morning coffee. It’s comforting, energising, and one of the biggest sources of antioxidants in the diet. But if you’ve also got an eye on your cholesterol and heart health, you’ve probably seen some confusing advice about filters, organic beans, and “super coffees.”

I have high overall cholesterol myself. When I was last tested (quite a few years ago now), my LDL wasn’t too bad, but I’ll have new results soon. In the meantime, I’ve been using paper filters for several years and also take plant sterol tablets to support healthy cholesterol. I wanted to share what I’ve learned — and what really matters when it comes to coffee and antioxidants. At home, I use a Melitta drip filter coffee maker with unbleached paper filters. I find it really easy to use, and I love that I can set the timer so there’s hot coffee waiting when I wake up. The insulated jug keeps it warm for hours, which is brilliant when I come back later in the day.

If you’d like to see the updated version of my coffee machine, you can find it here:👉 Melitta Coffee Machine on Amazon

This is an affiliate link, which means I may earn a small commission if you decide to buy — at no extra cost to you. Please note that the link will only track if you accept cookies when prompted by Amazon.

☕ Coffee and Cholesterol

Coffee naturally contains oils called cafestol and kahweol. These are a mixed bag:

• They have antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effects.

• But they also raise LDL cholesterol when they’re not filtered out.

The fix is simple: paper filters.

• Unfiltered coffee (French press, Turkish, stovetop moka) → raises LDL.

• Metal or stainless filters → let the oils through.

• Paper-filtered coffee (like in drip filter machines) → removes most of the LDL-raising compounds while keeping the main antioxidants (polyphenols like chlorogenic acids).

So, if cholesterol is a concern, paper filters are the safest choice.

🍃 Do You Need “Super” Coffee?

Some premium UK brands market themselves as healthier than standard coffee. For example:

• Exhale – highlights high antioxidant levels and testing for moulds.

• TrueStart (Bristol) – promotes “clean energy” coffee with stable caffeine release.

• Balance Coffee (London) – speciality coffee lab-tested for moulds, pesticides, and toxins.

These coffees can be a great option if you enjoy their flavour, branding, or the reassurance of extra testing and organic sourcing. At the same time, it’s reassuring to know that a supermarket coffee brewed with a paper filter still provides plenty of antioxidants and the same heart-healthy benefits.

🌱 “Toxin-Free” Coffee – What Does It Mean?

High-end brands often highlight being 100% toxin-free, mould-free, pesticide-free, and 100% Arabica. Here’s what that means:

• Mould & Mycotoxins

  • Mycotoxins (produced by fungi) can contaminate beans, but in the UK and EU, all coffee sold is already tested and regulated to stay well below safe limits. Premium brands test every batch themselves and highlight this in their marketing.

• Pesticides

  • Conventional coffee may use pesticides, but washing, roasting, and brewing greatly reduce residues. Safety levels in supermarket coffee are tightly regulated.

  • Organic avoids synthetic pesticides altogether — good for the environment and farmers — but for consumers, the difference is minimal.

• Arabica vs Robusta

  • Arabica beans have a smoother taste, less bitterness, and slightly higher levels of antioxidants.

  • Many supermarket coffees are already 100% Arabica.

  • Robusta has more caffeine and is less expensive, but it is not harmful.

  • 
    

✅ Takeaway: Premium testing and organic sourcing are reassuring, but for everyday health in the UK, your supermarket coffee is already safe.

Paper Filterred Coffee

🌙 What About Decaf Coffee?

If you cut down on caffeine — for sleep, anxiety, or other reasons — decaf is still a healthy choice.

• Antioxidants: Decaf retains most of its antioxidants, although a small amount is lost during the decaffeination process.

• Cholesterol oils: The LDL-raising oils (cafestol/kahweol) are still present, so paper filters are just as important with decaf.

• Caffeine-free benefit: Lets you enjoy coffee’s taste and antioxidants without disturbing sleep.

• 
  

✅ Takeaway: Decaf gives you most of the benefits of coffee, without the caffeine. Filter it the same way as regular.

🫐 Other Everyday Antioxidant-Rich Foods

Coffee isn’t the only source of antioxidants. Here are some everyday foods and drinks, with their extra health benefits:

• Berries – Brain & blood vessel health, reduce inflammation.

• Grapes/plums/cherries – Circulation & heart support.

• Leafy greens – Eye health, immunity, iron & folate.

• Broccoli & sprouts – Anti-cancer compounds, fibre-rich.

• Beans & lentils – Lower cholesterol, balance blood sugar, plant protein.

• Nuts – Heart & brain health, reduce LDL.

• Olives & EVOO – Anti-inflammatory, protect the heart.

• Avocado – Raise HDL (“good” cholesterol), lower LDL.

• Dark chocolate (70%+) – Blood pressure & circulation support.

• Green tea – Weight & heart health.

• Black tea – Antioxidant, heart supportive.

• Herbal teas (rooibos, hibiscus) – Antioxidant, may lower blood pressure.

• Spices – Anti-inflammatory and antioxidant power.

  
  

Some Antioxidant-Rich Foods

🍷 A Note on Red Wine

A small glass of red wine occasionally can provide antioxidants like resveratrol. But the line between benefit and harm is thin:

• A small amount (125ml, approximately once or twice a week) may be beneficial.

• Too much raises risks for blood pressure, liver disease, and certain cancers.

If you don’t drink, there’s no need to start.

🕑 Coffee, Caffeine & Sleep

Caffeine has a half-life of ~6 hours. That means half your afternoon coffee is still in your system at bedtime.

• Try to avoid caffeine within 6–8 hours of sleep.

• Switch to decaf or herbal tea later in the day.

✅ Do’s and Don’ts

Do: ✔ Use paper filters (not metal) ✔ Add antioxidant foods daily ✔ Enjoy 2–4 cups of coffee a day if it suits you ✔ Switch to decaf in the afternoon if sleep is affected

Don’t: ✘ Rely only on coffee for antioxidants ✘ Assume expensive “super” coffee is essential ✘ Drink lots of unfiltered coffee if cholesterol is high

📄 Download Your Quick Reference GuideIf you’d like an easy one-page version to save or print, I’ve put everything into a simple handout. It’s a handy checklist with the key points on coffee, cholesterol, antioxidants, and healthy swaps.

Coffee_Antioxidants_Handout.docx

Download DOCX • 38KB

💡 Final Thoughts

Coffee can be an integral part of a healthy lifestyle — whether you prefer regular or decaf. Using a paper filter is the single most important step for protecting cholesterol. Beyond that, focus on a colourful diet of fruits, veg, beans, nuts, olive oil, and even a little dark chocolate.

You don’t need to spend a fortune on “super” coffee to protect your health.

Thanks for reading — I hope this clears up some of the confusion about coffee, cholesterol, and antioxidants. As always, I’m sharing what I've learned on my own wellness journey in the hope that it supports you too.

I’d love to hear your thoughts — do you drink paper-filtered, unfiltered, or decaf coffee at home? Let’s keep the conversation going in our Fitness Dynamics Members’ Community.

Warm wishes, Sam 🌿

🔎 References

• Weusten-Van der Wouw MP et al. Boiled coffee raises serum cholesterol. N Engl J Med (1991)

• Urgert R, Katan MB. The cholesterol-raising factor from coffee beans. Annu Rev Nutr (1997)

• Uppsala University (2025): Cholesterol-elevating substances in coffee from machines at work

• NutritionFacts.org – Paper-Filtered Coffee and Cholesterol

• Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health – Coffee (The Nutrition Source)

• Harvard T.H. Chan – Ask the Expert: Coffee and Health

• Harvard Gazette – Coffee as a Health Drink?